After the Communist victory
in the civil war of 1949, some 1.3 million refugees from Mainland China
came to Taiwan. It was a time when the island was governed by a dictatorship
in which all political parties other than the Kuomintang were outlawed,
and political opponents were persecuted, jailed, and executed, a continuation
of the White Terror campaign launched after the 2/28 incident. Uncertain
about their future and shaken by the weakening of family traditions, immigrant
teenagers joined street gangs like the Little Park Gang and fought against
indigenous island groups such as the 217 to strengthen their sense of security.
There have been many great
films about the teenage years, but few capture the roller coaster emotions,
the sudden shifts of friendships and loyalties, the insularity and the
need to belong as authentically as Edward Yang’s epic four-hour masterpiece
A Brighter Summer Day. The film about Taiwanese youth looking for their
place in the world takes place in 1960, eleven years after the defeat of
Chiang Kai-shek in the Communist Revolution of 1949, and is based on an
actual incident that occurred in Taipei in which a 14 year-old boy killed
his 13-year old girlfriend, the first juvenile homicide in Taiwan’s history.
Shot mostly in darkness,
much of the action takes place at night or inside houses, schools, or dance
clubs, producing a feeling of growing anxiety. As detailed as a novel,
the film lasts almost four hours but nothing seems superfluous and the
darkness and uncertainty build slowly towards a powerful and inevitable
climax.
Young actors were recruited
from Taiwan schools and trained for the film over a period of years by
Edward Yang, then a teacher in the drama department of the National Institute
for the Arts and the performances are impeccable. There are 100 speaking
parts in the film though we get to know the characters only by their gang
names such as Airplane, Sly, Cat, Worm, Animal, Underpants, Honey, Elephant,
Tiger, and Ma.
Xiao S’ir is one of five
children and is considered a top prospect to enter college. Chen Chang,
who went on to star in such films as Happy Together, 2046, and Crouching
Tiger, Hidden Dragon, portrays S’ir as a bright and sensitive 14-year old
but lacking in respect for authority. Drawn into the culture of gangs,
he is ultimately driven to defend what he conceives to be his honor without
considering the consequences. His father (Guozhu Zang) is a civil servant
who sees his influence waning and his pleas to school officials to forgive
S’ir’s transgressions often fall on deaf ears. The father is arrested by
the police and badgered to reveal his associates in China which brings
an added strain to the already vulnerable family.
The influence of other
cultures also creates confusion. Both the use of Japanese swords as murder
weapons and American music including an Elvis Presley song play a major
role in the film and the family’s complaint that they fought against the
Japanese for years and now are living in a Japanese house listening to
Japanese songs is revealing. As the teens struggle to come to terms with
an increasingly chaotic world, an offhand remark often leads to unverifiable
conclusions and a chain of events that veers out of control. S’ir’s world
begins to unravel when he falls for a would-be actress named Ming (Lisa
Yang) who is the girlfriend of Honey (Lin Hongming), a soulful gang leader
who had killed one of Ming’s suitors and gone into exile.
When Honey is murdered
by Shandong (Alex Yang), a rival gang leader, an all-out confrontation
between gangs takes place in a driving rainstorm. As a result of Honey’s
death, Ming becomes all too available to S’ir’s friends, a circumstance
that leads to tragedy and the loss of a once promising future, perhaps
a metaphor for the island itself. Like Hou Hsiao-hsien’s City of Sadness,
A Brighter Summer Day is not a political film but a work of art that shows
how individual experience is impacted by the flow of time and history.
Interweaving social and
political events into a very personal experience, the film touches us with
its lyricism, the authenticity of its awareness, and its genuine caring
for its characters. Though sweeping in scope, it is full of touchingly
intimate moments and, for all the tough talk of the gang members, the characters
have an endearing sweetness and innocence, sadly lost forever in an unthinking
moment.
GRADE: A
Howard
Schumann