The American starring George Clooney is advertised as a Euro-style
thriller, most likely because it is so slow paced that it simply could
not be offered to the American public as a thriller or action flick,
you know the ones in which we tolerate the story line in order to get
to the next explosion, car chase, or special effect. Here we don't even
have to worry about the story line because there simply isn't any (or
at least not much of one). The film is directed by Anton Corbijn whose
previous work Control about the life of Ian Curtis, the lead singer of
the band Joy Division was, for me, an extremely moving experience.
Based on the novel A Very Private Gentleman by Martin Booth, George
Clooney is Jack (and later Ed), a professional assassin who goes about
his work with the enthusiasm of a reanimated corpse. Jack is a mostly
unsympathetic character - silent, secretive, and unsmiling whom we
first meet in a snowy field in Sweden killing his presumed antagonists
with no more emotion than in eating a Big Mac. We learn nothing about
how he got to this point, where he is going, or what he thinks about
either. The only thing we really do know about him is that he takes his
orders from Pavel (Johan Leysen), a sleazy-looking man that you would
not want to have over for dinner.
Jack is redirected to Italy by Pavel while he awaits his next
assignment. Told to lose himself, Jack avails himself of a blue Fiat
and travels to a village in the Abruzzo region, not far from Rome. Not
trusting anyone, which seems to be de rigueur for a man in his
profession, Jack moves to Castel del Monte where he avoids being shot
at by some revengeful Swedes and takes up with Clara (Violante
Placido), a local prostitute of remarkable grace and beauty, who calls
him Mr. Butterfly because of the tattoo on his back. He also meets
Father Benedetto (Paolo Bonacelli), a cliché-spouting priest who
doesn't believe Jack's story that he is a landscape photographer and
urges him to confess, but our reticent protagonist is not quite ready.
In another strange touch, Mathilde (Thekla Reuten) comes to Jack asking
him to build a high powered rifle for her to use (probably not in duck
hunting). Becoming more and more fearful of everything and everyone,
Jack simply wants to finish this last job and retire to some island
with Clara whom he has developed a nice relationship (that doesn't
include smiling or talking) but the fates and the movie's script's
demands rule otherwise. While The American has some of the feeling of
the great European classics of the 70s such as Melville's Le Samourai,
its portrayal of a lonely, depressed assassin who is good with
mechanics and prostitutes suddenly trying to find his humanity is
singularly unconvincing.
I'm all for people developing a conscience but in the case of a hit man
who early in the film murders a girl he slept with, it is a bit much.
Though The American is thoughtful and well crafted and the acting is
outstanding, it offers little to those who are looking for an escape
from having one's senses assaulted by films showing violence as the
best solution to our nagging problems. While Clooney's character wants
out of his lifestyle, his motivation remains as unclear as the earlier
motivation that fed his career choice. While I support European-style
character studies with an appeal geared to adults rather than children,
is it too much to ask for films in which violence is not a way of life?
Now that would be truly grown up.
GRADE: B-