"It's paradoxical but
living grows on you" - Professor Rémy
Denys Arcand's The
Barbarian Invasions is a touching film about family healing that won
the award for Best Screenplay and Best Actress for Marie-Josée Croze
at the last Cannes Film Festival and has been nominated for Best Foreign
Film at the upcoming Golden Globe Awards. Set in a crowded hospital in
Montreal and on Lake Memphremagog in Southern Quebec, a group of seven
friends and lovers gather to say farewell to History professor and unabashed
womanizer, Rémy (Rémy Girard) who is slowly dying of cancer.
The film reprises the characters first introduced in Arcand's The Decline
of the American Empire seventeen years ago and they come across as
real people honestly searching for meaning and reconciliation. Though the
film is about death and dying, it is filled with intelligence, humour,
high energy, and commitment to life.
The film centres on Rémy's
estranged relationship with his son Sebastian (stand-up comic Stéphane
Rousseau) a millionaire London businessman. When Sebastian comes to Montreal
with his fiancée (Marina Hands), years of resentment against his
father boil to the surface. Rémy apparently was not an exemplary
father figure. He cheated on his wife, over indulged himself in hedonistic
pleasures, and offered less than the support his children needed. Rémy,
a socialist, considers his son a "puritanical capitalist" and one who portends
the coming "barbarian" invasions. Sebastian resents Rémy for his
womanizing and calls him "contentious". In spite of this resentment, however,
he starts throwing money around to try and make his father's final days
more comfortable, in a way subtly letting his father know that money can
buy anything.
Sebastian "persuades"
hospital administrators to provide a private room for him on an unused
floor and bribes union leaders to fix it up. He enlists Diane's daughter,
Nathalie (Marie-Josée Croze), a tortured heroin addict into providing
drugs to alleviate Rémy's pain. This allows Arcand to throw in some
digs at the Canadian medical system and the puritanical drug laws in both
Canada and the U.S. that deny adequate relief for a patient's pain. Sebastian
contacts Remy's old friends from the university and brings them to the
hospital. These include Remy's tolerant former wife Louise (Dorothée
Berryman), department head and ex-lover Dominique (Dominique Michel), and
three fellow professors: Pierre (Pierre Curzi), Claude (Yves Jacques),
and Diane (Louise Portal). During his hospital stay, Rémy is comforted
by Sister Constance (Johanne Marie Tremblay) who puts up with his anti-Catholic
remarks and tells him to "embrace the mystery".
When Rémy is released,
all meet at a cottage by a lake for a final group discussion that includes
jokes about sex and past failures and discussions about 9/11, American
cultural domination, and all the "isms" they once believed in. Though still
full of spirit, Rémy admits that he feels as if his life never measured
up to his dreams. The Barbarian Invasions is not a perfect film
by any means but is one of the strongest Canadian films of recent years.
Though some of the dialogue is strained, underneath there is a humanity
that allows us to connect with our feelings about our own mortality and
our relationships with those we care about. It is often hard to reconcile
the robustly alive Rémy with our pictures of a man dying of cancer
but Girard is powerfully effective in the role and I went from quiet distaste
of his amorality to full acceptance of who he is by the end of the film.
Though the conclusion is emotional, it is not trite or overly sentimental
but allows us to access the deep place of silence within ourselves and
embrace the mystery.
Howard
Schumann