The plot of The Cook,
The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover centres on tyrannical restaurant
owner Albert Spica (Michael Gambon) who often dines at his extravagant
eatery accompanied by his wife Georgina (Helen Mirren) and several lackeys.
Unbeknown to him though, his wife is escaping from her loveless marriage
by partaking in an affair with one of the restaurant’s patrons, Michael
(Alan Howard). Upon finding this out, Albert decides to teach the
pair a lesson. However, he does not reckon on his wife’s own novel
plan for revenge…
The most arresting elements
of this film are undoubtedly the sumptuous visuals, with the ostentatious
style matching well with Gambon’s character: considering the nature of
Albert Spica, it is not hard to believe that he would choose this particular
style for his restaurant. The lighting is particularly eye-catching,
with a different colour used for each of the restaurant’s rooms and projected
onto the characters as well, creating a surreal, dreamlike effect.
The visual elements are also complimented perfectly by the dramatic, classical
score. The aesthetic may have a slight late 1980s vibe yet it still
feels as original as when the film was first released and does not fail
to make an impression. Indeed, while opinions on the film as a whole
may vary, it is hard to deny that it is one of the most striking and lavish
visions ever put to screen
The cast here is first-rate,
especially Michael Gambon in what is perhaps his finest role. Turning
in a gleefully wicked performance as the greedy, vulgar and conceited gangster/restaurateur,
he sets about the role with relish and creates one of cinema’s greatest
villains. Helen Mirren meanwhile does an excellent job of charting
her character’s progression: she is initially glamorous yet detached, in
keeping with her character’s unhappy relationship, yet as the film progresses
and Georgina embarks on a relationship with Michael, her strength and sensuality
come into the fore. Alan Howard’s role is not that substantial yet
he portrays the required sensitivity, which provides a counterpoint to
Gambon’s character and helps us identify with Georgina’s actions.
Although this is not a
mainstream film, it is by no means inaccessible- something that cannot
be said of some of Greenaway’s other output. It may not be to everyone’s
taste due to its avant-garde style and controversial nature but it is not
as pretentious as one might imagine. This is certainly no popcorn flick,
yet the director has crafted his most complete and audience-friendly film
without betraying his art house sensibilities. This is a hard balance
to achieve but Greenaway pulls it off and for this alone, he should be
applauded.
Without revealing the
details, the notorious conclusion is as shocking and memorable as its reputation
suggests and proves a surprisingly fitting and satisfying end to the story.
It may seem extreme but the film as a whole is not what one would call
commonplace and so it seems only right that the ending should follow suit.
The actors’ skilful portrayal of their characters also helps in that we
sympathise with Georgina and want Albert to get his comeuppance.
In the end, Albert has lived a life of greed and so his punishment seems
an apt and natural conclusion.
Overall, The Cook,
The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover manages to be an art house film whilst
still being enjoyable and not alienating the viewers. It is not a
film for everyone- in fact, it is the very definition of a love it or hate
it affair- but it is nevertheless a stunningly original and memorable experience.
Lucinda
Ireson