Agnieszka Holland is
a middle-ranking Polish director who has been active for over 30 years.
She has worked with such leading figures as Zanussi, Wajda, and Kieslowski,
though the best-known films in the UK which she has directed herself are
from outside Poland: To Kill a Priest (1988), Europa, Europa
(1990), The Secret Garden (1993), and Washington Square (1997).
Another American film, The Third Miracle (1999), had a modest theatrical
success in the U.S.A. but slipped out unnoticed on video in the U.K.
Her films often feature child actors in central roles. Her latest,
Julie Walking Home, is a Canadian-Polish-German co-production, set
mostly in Canada but with scenes in Poland and (in a prologue) Russia.
Based loosely on a true
story of a friend of Holland’s, Julie Walking Home tells of a mother
(Miranda Otto) whose young son Nicolas (Ryan Smith) suddenly develops what
appears to be terminal cancer. Hearing of the amazing achievements
of a Russian faith-healer Alexis (Lothaire Bluteau) in her father’s homeland
of Poland, she flies over there, and Alexis duly works his magic.
What she doesn’t bargain for is that she and the healer fall in love, and
arrange to spend time together at a friend’s house back in Canada.
Alexis has never had dealings with a woman before, so Julie teaches him
the ropes. After the consummation Alexis loses his powers, Nicolas
falls mortally sick again, and Julie’s husband Henry (William Fichtner)
goes berserk over the whole situation.
This sounds like the plot
of a rather bad TV melodrama, not without justification; it is a kind of
variation on the Samson and Delilah story (the strong man loses his powers
via a woman). However, there are some interesting ideas along the
way which could have been further developed. In particular, the family
members react in different ways to Nicolas’ original illness. Julie’s
father, a Polish Catholic, seeks to have him baptised; Henry, a non-religious
Jew and scientist, insists that things just have to be accepted; Nicolas’
twin sister tries magical rituals; Julie herself, hearing about Alexis
from her father’s mail-order bride(!), forsakes her nominal Catholicism
in favour of the faith-healer.
The film is beautifully
shot and acted, particularly by Miranda Otto, though personally I can do
without the fashionable documentary-style hand-held camerawork, presumably
intended to reflect the restlessness of modern life. It is interesting
how the Canadian actor Lothaire Bluteau, as Alexis, seems typecast in this
kind of role; he played a remarkably similar character in a film by another
Polish director Krzysztof Zanussi, The Silent Touch (1992), though
the best role in which I have seen him is as the protagonist in Denys Arcand’s
superb Jesus of Montreal (1989).
The version of Julie
Walking Home which I saw had Polish subtitles, which meant that the
bits of dialogue in Polish or Russian were lost on me; this did not, however,
detract from understanding what was going on. I’m also not clear
as to the precise meaning of the title, nor do I know (at the time of writing)
when a U.K. release will be forthcoming. If and when it appears it
is well worth seeing, but probably no more than once; in other words, it
is the kind of film which is given a rating of 3, perhaps 4, stars out
of 5.