Lan Yu, directed
by Hong Kong director Stanley Kwan, is melodrama on the rocks with a gay
twist. Based on the Internet novel Beijing Story, in Beijing in
1988, a middle-aged businessman Chen Handong (Jun Hu) picks up a young
architecture student Lan Yu (Ye Liu) for some quick sex but neither anticipates
the messy business of emotional involvement. Handong is a partner in a
trading company and lavishes expensive gifts on the boy who begins to feel
an attachment to him. The older man is very cautious, however, and tells
the boy, "When two people get to know each other too well, it's time to
separate".
Handong decides to marry
Jingping, a professional translator but the marriage fails and Handong
goes back to Lan Yu. Their plans for a long-term commitment are thwarted,
however, when Handong faces imprisonment as a result of his business' use
of shady tactics to remain afloat during a period of market instability
after Tiananmen Square. Handong turns to Lan Yu for financial help and
both acknowledge their love for each other but the relationship that has
survived for nine years is now up against the inexorability of fate. If
this sounds to you like a Chinese version of Love Story, you would
not be far off. Lan Yu takes us on an emotional roller coaster but
does not explore much depth of feelings or insight. Though the film is
honest in dealing with fear of commitment, I found the characters uninteresting
and the relationship lacking authenticity. Mr. Kwan is to be commended
for the courage it took to shoot this film in Beijing without official
Government approval, but the film's sketchiness and predictability rob
it of any enduring power.