Set in an unnamed African country embroiled in a
brutal civil war after transitioning from French colonialism to
independence, the insanity of war has never received a more graphic
portrayal than in Claire Denis' White Material. Named to reflect the
contempt in which blacks hold the white colonialists, it is a film
gripped by tension, violence, and eventual madness, but with a strong
sense of place and a remarkable feeling of authenticity. Though White
Material is less elliptical than many of her films which entice viewers
to fill in the gaps with their own imagination, its lack of background
information and non-linear chronology can make it, at least initially,
a somewhat disorienting experience.
Running a coffee plantation in the midst of the chaos, Maria Vial
(Isabelle Huppert) lives with her ex-husband André (Christopher
Lambert), her father-in-law Henri (Michel Subor) who owns the
plantation, and her layabout teenage son, Manuel (Nicholas
Duvauchelle). She insists on business as usual despite the fact that
her workers have abandoned their jobs out of fear of the child soldiers
who make up the bulk of the rebel army. Pursued by the government
militia, a wounded rebel leader (Isaach De Bankole), known only as “the
Boxer”, takes refuge at the plantation, increasing the possibility of
retaliation.
Maria is warned by French soldiers from a helicopter that she should
leave the country for her safety and that of her family, but she is
proudly, if not blindly, determined to maintain the role that has
always brought her security, though it is obvious from the first scene
showing her alone on a road, that she has already been stripped of her
colonial privileges. As author Andrew Sullivan once said, “When there's
a challenge to our established world-view, whether from the absurd, the
unexpected, the unpalatable, the confusing or the unknown, we
experience a psychological force pushing back, trying to re-assert the
things we feel are safe, comfortable and familiar.”
Refusing to face the inevitable, Maria goes into the village to recruit
other workers, insisting that her coffee crop must be harvested, though
it is unclear who she expects to sell it to. Without her knowledge,
André begins to make arrangements to leave on his own and tries
to make a deal with the mayor (William Nadylam) to sell the property.
Even her son does not escape the madness. After being brutally attacked
and stripped by young rebels, Manuel shaves off all of his hair, grabs
a loaded rifle, and joins the rebel soldiers.
In one of the most telling scenes, after several pharmacists are
murdered, the rebel soldiers, who include both young boys and girls,
sit on the grass ingesting the stolen drugs as if they were on a
picnic.
Despite the violence in White Material, there are some lovely moments
evoked by cinematographer Yves Capes: wild dogs on a dirt road
illuminated by the headlights of a car, the sounds of reggae music
broadcasted by a disc jockey who promotes rebel causes, and the sight
of Maria hanging onto the ladder of a bus filled with black refugees.
Considering the depth and breadth of Denis' filmography, White Material
may be a minor film, yet it is a graceful work of art, filled with a
dreamlike quality that makes a strong statement about the dehumanizing
effects of war, regardless of the rightness of the cause.
GRADE: A-