Paddy Considine
is Richard, a returning soldier who seeks atonement for the torment and
humiliation his mentally-challenged brother Anthony (Toby Kebbell)
suffered at the hands of the drug dealers and lowlifes while Richard
was in the Army. Set in the English midlands among ancient castles and
rolling farmlands, Shane Meadows’ (This is England) fifth feature, Dead
Man’s Shoes, is more than a by-the-numbers story of revenge against
those who bully weaker, vulnerable people. It is a black comedy with a
serious message – that unchecked violence, regardless of the
righteousness of the cause, brings the perpetrator to the same level as
his victims. While this theme has been done before, rarely has it been
brought to the screen with such unnerving intensity and brutal
realism.
Divided into five day-chapters, Dead Man’s Shoes opens with two men
walking through rural Derbyshire to the background song “Vessel in
Vain” by the English group Smog. Captured by cinematographer Danny
Cohen, it sets an idyllic tone but one that is soon interrupted by the
man carrying a backpack who says to the camera: “God will forgive them.
He'll forgive them and allow them into Heaven. I can't live with that,"
and then sets out methodically to prove his point. Richard, an
ex-paratrooper, has a grim, determined look that almost belies the
humiliating pranks he initially plays on his victims, painting their
faces while sleeping and leaving cryptic messages on their walls before
he moves on to more relentless punishments.
The first time we see Richard’s fangs is when he is confronted by gang
member Herbie (Stuart Wolfenden), at a pub who menacingly asks him,
“What are you looking at?” only to met by teeth-bearing rage and an
unprintable retort. The good-natured, semi-improvised dialogue of the
thugs (barely decipherable through thick accents) soon moves to the
ugliness of Richard’s bloody campaign to pick them off one by one.
While this occurs, Meadows provides black and white flashbacks to show
Richard’s justifications for his actions - the increasing abuse being
inflicted on Anthony who lacks the resources to stand up for
himself.
The film is dotted with memorable moments: the macho crime boss Sonny’s
(ex-boxer Gary Stretch) accidental shooting of Big Al (Seamus O’Neill)
after the five drive up in their tiny 2CV to the farmhouse where
Richard is staying; the face-to-face confrontation between Richard and
Sonny while the boys wait in the car; Richard donning a gas mask to
lurk about and scare the living daylights out of Herbie; a dark but
daringly realistic Speed and LSD trip in which the dealers experience
what they have inflicted on others; and a final plot twist that will
leave you gaping.
Dead Man’s Shoes is a riveting work whose power lies not only in the
staggeringly believable performance of Considine (who-co-wrote the
screenplay with Shane Meadows), but in the film’s dirge-like, almost
spiritual tone that is enhanced by the elegiac music of Arvo Part.
Ultimately, Richard’s belated attempt to redeem his guilt and rescue
his own soul suggests that retribution should be left to the universe
to sort out and that redemption can only lie in acknowledging and
taking responsibility for one’s own actions.