When Amanda McCready
(Madeline O'Brien), a four-year-old girl, goes missing from her Boston
residence for three days and Jack Doyle (Morgan Freeman), the head of the
police’s Crimes Against Children’s Unit whose own daughter was kidnapped
and murdered, is unable to produce any suspects, two private detectives
are hired by the little girl’s Aunt Bea (Amy Madigan) and Uncle Lionel
(Titus Welliver). Somewhat reluctantly, Patrick Kenzie (Casey Affleck)
and his partner Angie Gennaro (Michelle Monaghan) agree to take the case
even though they are aware that Amanda’s distraught mother Helene (Amy
Ryan) is a cocaine addict with nefarious connections.
Crime dramas, police procedurals,
and suspense thrillers usually bombard us with buckets full of murder and
mayhem but rarely stop to question the morality of vigilante justice. That
is what makes Ben Affleck’s Gone Baby Gone such a rarity. Co-written by
Aaron Stockard and based on a Dennis Lehane novel, it is a film that asks
us to think about whether a noble purpose justifies an illegal act and
whether murder is any more justified if dispensed by those in charge of
public safety than by ruthless criminals. The first half of the film is
gritty and authentic in its depiction of the mean streets of South Boston
and Affleck’s credibility in the role is enhanced by an understated vulnerability
which masks his quiet power.
Working with veteran detective
Remy Bressant (Ed Harris) and his partner Nick Poole (John Ashton), they
follow leads to the local bar. Utilizing his local connections, Patrick
uncovers the fact that Helene has stolen a large amount of money from a
Haitian gangster named Cheese (Edi Gathegi) and they suspect that he is
holding the little girl for ransom. Though a raid on Cheese’s apartment
yields no results, a subsequent phone call sets up a meeting to transfer
the money for Amanda but the exchange is botched. From here, the film wanders
into unexplored territory that is guaranteed to be a major topic of discussion.
Impeccably acted by an
outstanding ensemble cast, Gone Baby Gone is a powerful film that keeps
us riveted until the end. Though some may question the veracity of the
twist ending, it does raise pertinent issues about how best to protect
the innocence of children in a society in which 2,000 children are reported
missing every day. Turning from a standard kidnapping narrative, the film
raises issues of the interests of society versus individual rights, and
whether the end can ever justify the means.