Ida
is the latest from Pawel Pawlikowski (Last
Resort, My Summer of Love) and his first feature
made in his native Poland. As such, it has
proved a critical and (for an "art house" film)
commercial success. In France
it has broken box-office records for any
non-French or non-English language film, while
in Poland, where films about Polish history have
always been hugely popular, it has
unsurprisingly proved a smash hit. I
predict that it will feature very strongly in
critics' "best releases of 2014" lists,
following its "best film" award at the 2013
London Film Festival.
The first thing that strikes the viewer is that,
like the multi-Oscar-winning The Artist, it has
the appearance of an old movie, in fact like one
that might have been made in 1961, the year it
is set. In black-and-white and shot in
Academy ratio, it is actually stunningly
photographed, much of it in the wintry Polish
countryside, with a mostly static camera.
Its themes are several: the relationship between
Catholicism and Communism in 1960s Poland, the
fate of the Jews and their historically uneasy
relationship with other Poles, the personality
clash between two very different women, the
nature of commitment to a vocation. The
central character is Anna, a young nun, brought
up in a convent, and about to take her final
vows, who discovers that she was born a Jew
named Ida (pronounced Eeda) and that her family
were victims of the Holocaust. Her only
living relative is an aunt, who works as a judge
for the Communist regime but seeks solace in
alcohol and men. These two women go in
search of where and how Ida's family met their
end (the film is what would now be called a
road-movie) and, following an unexpected
traumatic event, Ida has to decide whether to
continue with her vocation.
The two leads are played superbly, Ida by a
hypnotic newcomer, the aunt by a seasoned
regular in Polish TV and cinema. There is
some great jazz music, John Coltrane style, once
a third character, a young saxophonist, appears
on the scene. With its underlying
spirituality and gleaming monochrome
photography, Ida reminds this viewer, at least,
of Robert Bresson's mid-period masterpieces,
such as Mouchette. And after two viewings,
I think it is just as good.