A BBC,
Time-Life production from the early 1980s, this TV adaptation of A
Midsummer Night’s Dream has all of Shakespeare’s words but none of the
magic. Trying to ensure that none of the text is left out, the actors
deliver their lines at a breakneck pace, almost sounding like the
debating team in Rocket Science. Consequently, much of Shakespeare’s
nuance and poetry is lost. This is a play that relies on myth and
allegory to make its point which is essentially that reality is
malleable and can be influenced by the spirit world for either good or
ill, yet its treatment here is cumbersome and heavy-handed rather than
light and playful.
The play, replete with allusions to Greek mythology, is about a trio of
mixed-up lovers: Hermia, Denetrius, and Lysander. Hermia’s overbearing
father Egeus is partial to Demetrius, his choice to be Hermia’s
husband. Indeed, Egeus’ description in the play’s first scene of his
love for Demetrius sounds suspiciously like Shakespeare’s entreaties to
the fair youth in the Sonnets. In the same vein, Duke Theseus, who is
marrying former enemy Hippolyta, sounds the refrain that the duty of a
beloved youth is to make a copy of himself to preserve for future
generations. Meanwhile Hermia is fixated on Lysander and will not
consider anyone else as a husband, although choosing to disobey her
father may lead to a potential death sentence or life as a nun which
may be the same thing. To escape, Hermia agrees to run off with
Lysander into the forest but naively conveys the information to Helena,
a young maiden who longs for Demetrius.
She follows Demetrius into the forest to try and stop Hermia and
Lysander but they come upon a group of fairies who have their own
agenda, leading to a romantic farce of mistaken identities caused by
the fairies magical potions. One of the subplots concerns a theatrical
troupe of workers who offer a play within a play that bring the
proceedings to a comic high. The cast is competent but uninspired with
the possible exception of Helen Mirren as The Faerie Queen. Nicky
Henson as Demetrius and Robert Lindsay as Lysander seem too old for the
part of young lovers and speak their lines with a clunky earnestness
that is all wrong for the mood. Phil Daniels plays Puck with a demonic
grin, belying the characters’ playful nature. All in all, work of
nimble grace is turned into an often incomprehensible shouting match
that makes one long for some of the magic fairies potion - to sleep,
perchance to dream.