When you are somewhere in the middle of it, a
great film like a great book often has a quality
that may feel random and unfocused, devoid of
structure or meaning. It is only when completed
that you can impose on it a retroactive unity
and see an aspect of its design that has not
been apparent. Such is the case with Derek
Cianfrance’s The Place Beyond the Pines, a
suspenseful and gripping multi-layered drama
that covers fifteen years in the life of its
protagonists (Bradley Cooper and Ryan Gosling).
A cautionary tale about the need to give up our
bravura posturing and communicate our pain to
others before the ripple effect of our actions
can no longer be contained, it is a sprawling
epic whose power can be better appreciated in
its totality.
Set in a working class area of Schenectady, New
York, the film opens as Luke Glanton (Ryan
Gosling), a brawny, tattooed man with bleached
blond hair is performing a daredevil feat at a
traveling carnival along with two other riders.
They race around and past each other, often
upside down in a metal cage defying gravity.
Even though he is soft spoken with eyes that
look right through you, Luke is tightly wound
and always seems ready to erupt. While in town,
he visits ex-girlfriend Romina (Eva Mendes), a
waitress he once had an affair with, only to
discover that he is the father of her little boy
named Jason.
Feeling drawn once again to Romina even though
she is now living with a new man, Kofi
(Mahershala Ali), Luke takes a low-paying job as
a mechanic working with Robin (Ben Mendelsohn),
a reformed bank robber, to make extra money to
support his family. Unable to resist the
temptation, Luke and Robin team up and begin to
rob banks until a traumatic confrontation with a
rookie cop, Avery (Bradley Cooper) causes a
drastic change in direction and Cooper’s
character now becomes the film’s focus. Though
no one can match the charisma of Gosling and the
film does not maintain its high level of
intensity throughout, each part of the film is
engaging and powerfully-realized in its own way,
utilizing an impressive ensemble cast that
depicts real human beings, not cardboard
cutouts.
Though Avery, with tons of ambition hidden
beneath an outwardly calm demeanor, is
celebrated as a hero, he must contend with his
own feelings of remorse for an action performed
in the line of duty as well as with having to
deal with a corrupt cop, Deluca (Ray Liotta),
who recruits him to help in his illegal acts.
When DeLuca shows up with friends at Avery’s
house without an invitation, the undercurrent of
tension is palpable despite the camaraderie. The
film then hurtles forward fifteen years when
Luke and Avery’s volatile and alienated sons, AJ
and Jason, played to perfection by Emory Cohen
and Dane DeHaan, are now teenagers at the same
high school without knowledge of their past
connection.
As the two boys grapple for some understanding
of the circumstances that brought them together,
the film has comes full circle, beginning and
ending with a man on a motorcycle. One is going
around and around in a cage while the other is
going straight ahead towards an unknown
destination with a new feeling of confidence and
an air of transcendence.
GRADE: A